easy answers to “hey mom, what’s for dinner?” About Work With Us
hey mom,

Kitchen How-Tos

How to Reheat Prime Rib So It Stays Tender

Reheat prime rib covered in a low 250°F oven with a splash of jus, or slice it thin into simmering jus. Times by size, and the honest truth about 165°F.

How to Reheat Prime Rib So It Stays Tender

To reheat prime rib so it stays tender, warm it gently: either put a thick piece on a rack in a covered pan with a few spoonfuls of jus or broth in a 250°F oven until it is hot through, or slice it thin and slide the slices into jus brought to a boil and turned down to a simmer for a minute or two. Low heat and moisture keep the meat from drying into a gray band. One honest catch: the food-safety rule for reheated leftovers is 165°F, and prime rib at 165°F is no longer pink. That trade-off is explained below so you can make the call with the facts.

The times on this page are our starting points for fridge-cold prime rib, not lab figures. Use a thermometer the first time.

The 165°F problem, plainly

Prime rib is usually cooked to medium rare. South Dakota State University Extension tells you to pull the roast at 130 to 135°F for that. The same page then gives the rule for the leftovers: “heat them to an internal temperature of 165 degrees Fahrenheit to ensure food safety.” Illinois Extension says the same in its leftovers guidance: “reheat to a minimum of 165 F, the safe temperature needed to kill harmful bacteria that may be present.”

So a slice of medium-rare prime rib reheated to the leftovers standard will be well done. Most recipes for reheating prime rib stop well short of 165°F, or say “until warm”, and call it done. We will not print a lower “safe” number, because the food-safety sources we checked give one figure for reheated leftovers, and it is 165°F.

What a gentle method gives you is prime rib that reaches that temperature evenly, with the juice kept in. Thin slices in hot liquid heat through in a minute or two, so they spend less time in the heat and stay tender. The real choice is not pink against safe. It is juicy well-done slices against dry ones.

Method 1: covered in a low oven, for thick pieces

Best for a leftover end of the roast, or slices an inch thick or more.

  1. Heat the oven to 250°F. Set a wire rack in a small pan.
  2. Add moisture. Pour a few spoonfuls of leftover jus or beef broth into the bottom of the pan, under the rack.
  3. Cover the pan tightly with foil. The steam keeps the cut surfaces from drying out.
  4. Warm it through. Our rough times: 15 to 25 minutes for 1-inch slices, and 30 to 45 minutes or more for a 2 to 3 pound end piece. Check the center with an instant-read thermometer such as the TempPro TP19H.
  5. Serve it straight away, with the hot jus spooned over.

If you want some crust back, give thick slices 30 to 45 seconds a side in a very hot skillet after the oven, as you would a leftover steak.

Method 2: thin slices in hot jus, the gentle option

This is the fastest method, the most forgiving one, and the best for sandwiches the day after Christmas.

  1. Slice the cold prime rib thin, across the grain. Cold meat slices more neatly than warm.
  2. Bring the jus or broth to a rolling boil. NC State’s Safe Plates program says gravies and sauces should be brought to a rolling boil when reheated. Saved drippings count. About half a cup is plenty for a few sandwiches.
  3. Turn the heat down to low and add the slices for about 1 to 2 minutes, turning them, until hot through.
  4. Lift them out with tongs onto rolls or plates, and spoon a little jus over.

Thin slices heat through almost at once, which is why this method stays tender when the oven method on a thin slice would not.

Method 3: the microwave, if you must

It works, and it gives the worst texture, because the edges overcook before the middle warms. If it is all you have, slice the meat, lay the slices on a plate with a spoonful of jus, cover the plate, and heat at 50% power in 30-second bursts, turning the slices between them. Safe Plates gives two rules for microwaving any leftover: stir or turn partway through to break up cold spots, and cover the dish to heat it evenly.

Times by size

Fridge-cold prime rib, our times. Ovens and fridges vary.

PieceCovered oven, 250°FHot jus, sliced thin
Thin slices, 1/4 inchUse the jus method1 min
1-inch slices15 to 25 min1 to 2 min
1 1/2-inch slices25 to 35 minSlice thinner first
End piece, 2 to 3 lb30 to 45 min or moreSlice first

Storing it so there is something worth reheating

Illinois Extension says leftovers should be refrigerated or frozen within two hours of serving, and NC State’s Safe Plates program shortens that to one hour if the room is above 90°F. Put the meat in shallow, covered containers. SDSU says meat leftovers should be “eaten or frozen within four days of cooking”, and Illinois Extension gives 3 to 4 months for frozen leftovers.

Two habits that help:

  • Keep the leftover meat in one piece if you can. A chunk dries out less in the fridge than slices do. Slice it cold, just before reheating.
  • Save the jus. Pour it into its own container. It is the best reheating liquid you will have, and it does the job better than water or plain broth.

Reheat only what you will eat at that meal. Safe Plates advises against reheating leftovers more than once.

If you are still planning the roast, our chart of how much prime rib per person shows how many ribs to buy for the headcount, plus one extra if you want sandwiches. For everything else in the fridge after the holiday, the meal-prep reheating chart gives a method for each food.

FAQ

What is the best way to reheat prime rib?

For sandwiches and thin slices, a minute or two in jus that has been brought to a boil and turned down. For thick pieces, a covered pan with a little jus in a 250°F oven until hot through.

Can you reheat prime rib and keep it medium rare?

Not if you reheat it to the leftovers safety standard. SDSU and Illinois Extension both give 165°F for reheated leftovers, which is well done for prime rib. Gentle heat keeps it moist at that temperature, but it will not stay pink.

How long do you reheat prime rib in the oven?

At 250°F, covered, about 15 to 25 minutes for 1-inch slices and 30 to 45 minutes or more for a larger end piece. Go by the thermometer, not the clock.

Can you reheat prime rib in the microwave?

Yes, sliced, covered, with a spoonful of jus, at 50% power in short bursts. Expect a firmer, drier result than the oven or the jus method.

How long does leftover prime rib last?

SDSU says to eat or freeze meat leftovers within four days of cooking. Frozen, Illinois Extension gives 3 to 4 months.