easy answers to “hey mom, what’s for dinner?” About Work With Us
hey mom,

Freezer & Meal Prep

Can You Freeze Pumpkin Pie? Baked, Unbaked and Thawing

Yes. Pumpkin pie freezes baked or unbaked: wrap it tightly, eat it within a month or two, and thaw it in the fridge. Fridge times and the texture catch.

Can You Freeze Pumpkin Pie? Baked, Unbaked and Thawing Yes

Yes, you can freeze pumpkin pie, baked or unbaked. Cool a baked pie completely, wrap it tightly in plastic and then foil, freeze it, and eat it within about a month for the best texture. Extension charts allow up to 2 months. Thaw it in the fridge, never on the counter. An unbaked pie can be frozen ready to bake, thawed in the fridge and baked as the recipe says. One honest catch: pumpkin pie is a custard, and not every test kitchen likes how it freezes. Both sides are below, so you can decide how far ahead to bake.

How long pumpkin pie keeps in the fridge and freezer

Pumpkin pie is made with milk and eggs, so it belongs in the fridge. Iowa State University’s AnswerLine says it “should be refrigerated within two hours of cooling where it can be stored for 3 to 4 days”. Here is what the loaded charts say, side by side:

SourceFridgeFreezer
Iowa State AnswerLine3 to 4 daysBest within a month
University of Illinois Extension leftovers chart4 daysUp to 2 months
Cornell Cooperative Extension holiday chart3 to 4 days (baked)1 to 2 months (baked)

We plan on the shortest numbers: 3 to 4 days in the fridge, about a month in the freezer. The longer freezer figures are about quality, not safety. Iowa State puts it plainly: a pumpkin pie kept frozen longer than a month “does not go bad or cause concern for food borne illness, but its taste and texture may start to degrade.”

Store-bought pies are a little different. AnswerLine notes that commercial pumpkin pies “often have shelf-stable preservatives”, so follow the box for how long it can sit out, but refrigerate it once it has been cut.

Baked or unbaked: which freezes better?

Iowa State says pumpkin pie “of all kinds” freezes well, homemade or store-bought, whole or in slices, and “can be frozen ready-to-bake or baked.” It puts the success down to “careful wrapping, quick freezing, and thawing in the refrigerator.”

Cook’s Illustrated disagrees, and it is worth knowing why. In its freezing test, a baked pumpkin pie came out of the freezer with filling that was “grainy and wet, and the extra moisture made the crust soggy”, and an unbaked one did the same. Its explanation: pumpkin filling holds a lot of water from the dairy and the pumpkin, freezing damages the egg gel that holds it, and after thawing “some of it weeps out.”

So here is our take, from the kitchen rather than a lab:

  • Baking a few days ahead? Don’t freeze it. The fridge holds a baked pie for 3 to 4 days, which covers Wednesday-for-Thursday easily.
  • Baking a week or more ahead, or saving leftovers? Freeze it, wrapped well, and expect a slightly softer crust. A pie that would otherwise go in the bin is a fair trade for a little texture.
  • Want the best shot at a crisp crust? Make the crust ahead instead, and fill and bake it close to the day. Pecan pie is the better make-ahead holiday pie: Cook’s Illustrated found it froze “baked or unbaked with no ill effects.”

Freezing a baked pumpkin pie

  1. Cool it completely. Iowa State warns that trapped steam under the wrapping gives “a soggy pie.” Cool it on a rack, then chill it in the fridge before wrapping.
  2. Use a thin pan if you can. AnswerLine suggests a disposable aluminum pie pan when you bake a pie to freeze whole, because thin aluminum lets the pie freeze quickly. A pack of NoCry 9-inch disposable pie pans means you never have to give up your good pie dish for a month.
  3. Wrap twice. Plastic wrap first, pressed against the surface, then a layer of foil. Iowa State says this guards against “freezer burn and odor absorption from other items in the freezer.”
  4. Freeze it flat and uncovered by anything heavy until it is solid, so the top stays smooth.
  5. Label it with the date. A month goes fast in November.

Slices freeze too. Wrap each one the same way and put them in a Ziploc gallon freezer bag. A slice thaws overnight and makes a good lunchbox treat.

Skip the whipped cream before freezing. Add it after the pie has thawed.

Freezing an unbaked pumpkin pie

Iowa State’s AnswerLine allows a pie frozen ready to bake, and it also lets you freeze just the filling: make the recipe, freeze the custard in an airtight container or zip-top freezer bag, thaw it in the fridge, then pour it into a pie shell and bake as the recipe directs.

To bake a frozen unbaked pie, AnswerLine’s method is to unwrap it and let it thaw in the fridge “for at least 12 hours”, then bake. It may take longer than the recipe says if the filling is still cold. A pumpkin pie is done when it reaches 175°F in the center, by Iowa State’s figure. A knife or skewer pushed into the middle should come out clean, and the edges should be firm while the center still jiggles slightly. An instant-read thermometer settles it without guessing.

How to thaw frozen pumpkin pie

In the fridge, unwrapped, for at least 12 hours. Iowa State is specific about why not the counter: “Thawing at room temperature causes condensation on the pie resulting in a soggy pie crust.” That fits the two-hour rule too, since a custard pie should not sit out longer than that.

Pumpkin pie is good cold, so there is no need to warm it. If you like it warm, a short spell in a low oven is enough. It needs heating through, not cooking again.

Planning Thanksgiving pies around the freezer

If pie is one of several things you are making ahead, here is how we would order it:

  • The weekend before: pie crusts, frozen in the pan, and any cookie dough.
  • Two days before: bake the pumpkin pie and keep it in the fridge.
  • After the meal: freeze leftover slices within the fridge window. Our Thanksgiving leftovers chart has the fridge times for everything else on the table, and the guide to freezing cooked turkey covers the bird, gravy and stuffing.

For the Christmas baking that comes next, our post on baking Christmas cookies with kids is the easier make-ahead project.

FAQ

Can you freeze a store-bought pumpkin pie?

Yes. Iowa State says store-bought pumpkin pies freeze as well as homemade ones. Wrap it in plastic and foil, or freeze it in its own box inside a freezer bag, and thaw it in the fridge.

Does pumpkin pie need to be refrigerated?

Yes, homemade pumpkin pie does, within two hours of cooling, because the filling is made with milk and eggs. Store-bought pies may contain preservatives, so check the box, and refrigerate one once it has been cut.

How long does pumpkin pie last in the freezer?

Plan on about a month for the best texture. University of Illinois Extension allows up to 2 months. After that it is still safe if it stayed frozen, but the crust and filling get softer.

Can you refreeze pumpkin pie?

We wouldn’t. Each freeze and thaw lets more water out of the custard, so a refrozen pie comes back wetter. Freeze it in slices so you only thaw what you will eat.

Why did my frozen pumpkin pie get soggy?

Usually it was wrapped warm, or thawed on the counter. Both trap moisture on the crust. Cook’s Illustrated also found that freezing damages the custard itself, so some softening is normal.